Blog Details

To appear our most modern updates on the Nancy Guthrie case, please click on here.

The Pima County Sheriff’s Division—which is leading the investigation into Nancy Guthrie‘s abduction—used to be working on a reality TV notify correct months earlier than her disappearance that supplied producers in-depth catch entry to to the internal workings of its officers, a fresh record has published.

Based mostly entirely entirely on a trove of larger than 200 emails obtained by Fox Data, deputies working across extra than one departments had been instructed in June 2025 to work with producers from the A&E notify “Desert Law,” which aired in January of this yr, correct weeks earlier than Nancy, 84, used to be taken from her Arizona dwelling.

The exchanges—plenty of of which took role between producer Amanda Riley and Capt. Robert Koumal, who works in the neighborhood providers division—furthermore uncover that there had been extra than one staffing changes made across the department in the months leading as a lot as Nancy’s disappearance.

5 items, along with the homicide and chilly case departments, underwent a “reassignment” of management, primarily based on an email sent to Riley by Koumal, who wrote: “The department has experienced some rotational reassignments since last year.”

The most most modern email in the tranche of messages used to be sent in December 2025—lower than two months earlier than Nancy vanished from her Tucson-space dwelling. On the time of e-newsletter, the grandmother stays missing and no suspects had been named in her case.

Nonetheless, the messages furthermore uncover the department’s concerns about sure physique cam photographs being archaic in the notify.

Any individual with any recordsdata about Nancy Guthrie’s case would possibly per chance maintain to smooth call 1-800-CALL-FBI, 520-351-4900, 88-CRIME, or search the advice of with https://tricks.fbi.gov/.

A&E producers requested extra than one clips one day of the emails and, while it’s unclear what precisely used to be handed over by the PCSD, one among Koumal’s colleagues notes in a single email to the captain that he used to be disturbed about the usage of a video in which an officer archaic “profanities constantly” one day of a conversation with a discipline.

Regarding a separate share of physique cam photographs, the identical colleague admitted that an officer had “punch[ed] the suspect several times in the face,” while noting that the deputy did no longer “activate his body camera until well after the fight [was] over.”

Producers had previously highlighted the importance of the physique cam photographs in the notify, with one email sent by a member of the manufacturing team, Tom Olney, noting: “There is one area we’ve struggled with which would be great to get your input on.

“To notify the breadth of work the deputies and detectives enact, we maintain got been taking a study growing compelling narratives purely from physique weak digicam photographs at incidents we did no longer movie at—we are calling them retrospective incidents.”

The email then asked that members of the PCSD highlight specific “incidents” that might make for the “correct kind” for the show.

Olney also praised the department for being so supportive, saying: “Thank you as ever for all of your persevered toughen, it’s fantastic and fully the handiest I’ve ever got from any law enforcement department!”

However, he later raised concerns about the wait time for requested body cam footage and asked the PCSD to reprioritize which clips they were seeking to procure to focus on those that producers deemed most important.

The TV crew also went on several ride-alongs with the department and requested a public information officer be available to drive an SUV to obtain B-roll footage, to which Koumal agreed.

According to the emails, the A&E team also zeroed in on one historic case—the 1996 murder of Gary Triano, who died in an explosion in the Catalina Foothills after his wife, Pamela Phillips, enlisted a hitman to bomb his vehicle.

Phillips was convicted in 2014 and is serving life in prison. The bomber, Ron Young, was arrested in 2005 following an episode of “The US’s Most Wanted.”

Producers requested access to Triano’s vehicle, asking to film additional B-roll using the car, which was being held by the Pima County Sheriff’s Department, according to the messages.

Koumal also encouraged deputies to talk to the show producers “if any incidents happen.”

Pima County Sheriff Chris Nanos, who has been overseeing the investigation into Nancy’s disappearance, is no longer referenced in any of the messages.

Nonetheless, Nanos—and his department—maintain attain below increasing scrutiny in most modern weeks because the investigation into Nancy’s whereabouts appears to maintain hit plenty of major roadblocks.

Earlier this month, FBI sources tried to address at least 1 in all those hurdles, telling NewsNation and ABC Data that its genuine laboratory had in the end got a DNA pattern taken from Nancy’s dwelling, which had been present process attempting out in a internal most lab in Florida.

The insider famed that this DNA proof is no longer fresh, but had reasonably been extracted from a diversity of materials that had been smooth from Nancy’s Tucson-space situation in early February. That proof had previously been sent to a laboratory in Florida by the Pima County Sheriff’s Division and had solely correct been returned to the FBI bureau.

“There would possibly per chance be no longer any fresh DNA proof in the Nancy Guthrie case. The FBI requested this cloth over two months ago,” an FBI genuine instructed ABC Data.

“The Pima County Sheriff’s Jam of business sent it to a internal most lab in Florida. Eleven weeks later, that lab has now transferred an authorized hair pattern to the FBI Laboratory for attempting out. We remain fully dedicated to this investigation.”

According to the outlet, the FBI is now using “fresh abilities to habits evolved evaluation on the DNA pattern” to see whether it might provide information about Nancy’s alleged kidnappers.

Nanos—who has come under heavy criticism over his handling of the case—previously stated in March that authorities had collected several DNA samples from Nancy’s home, but that authorities were struggling to extract individual profiles from that evidence.

“It’s a anxiousness because we know we maintain got DNA, but now we maintain got to address that mixture and how we’re going to separate it,” he said.

Nanos revealed that investigators had run into some “challenges” in their examination of the evidence.

“We hear to our lab, and our lab tells us that there’s challenges with it, and we notice those challenges,” he instructed NBC News.

“But our lab furthermore knows that the abilities is intelligent so speedy and in the sort of frenzy that they judge a pair of of these items will resolve itself correct in a matter of weeks, months or even a yr, to enable them to enact better with, instruct, a mixture of that roughly thing.”

At the time, Nanos also noted that previous DNA samples that had been submitted to the Combined DNA Index System (CODIS), a database used by the FBI to track convicted criminals, have not resulted in a match, but that the additional evidence would be analyzed when they were “sorted out.”

“We judge that lets maintain some DNA there that is at chance of be our suspect, but we won’t know that until that DNA is separated, sorted out, possibly admitted to CODIS, possibly via genetic genealogy,” Nanos added.

Scam detection What’s the chunky timeline of Nancy Guthrie’s disappearance?

Nanos famed one day of a media briefing on Feb. 5 that, while cases are approximate, his team has pieced together plenty of issues of proof that uncover Nancy’s actions—and the timeline of her apparent abduction.

Nancy, 84, used to be reported missing at spherical 12 p.m. native time on Feb. 1, spherical 14 hours after she used to be dropped off on the property following a family dinner. When she did no longer flip up at her long-established church gathering on Sunday, her friends alerted her family, who chanced on her dwelling used to be empty.

SATURDAY, JAN. 31

5:32 p.m. Nancy travels to daughter Annie’s condo in an Uber for “dinner and enjoying games with the family.”

9:48 p.m. A garage door at Nancy’s house opens when she was dropped off at the property by her son-in-law, Tommaso Cioni.

9:50 p.m. The garage door closes, indicating that Nancy was inside the home.

SUNDAY, FEB. 1

1:47 a.m. Nancy’s doorbell security camera is disconnected.

2:12 a.m. Movement is detected on a security camera at the home.

2:28 a.m. Nancy’s pacemaker app indicates that the device has been disconnected from her phone.

11:00 a.m. Nancy fails to arrive at the home of a friend, where she had been due to watch a church service livestream.

11:56 a.m. Nancy’s family travels to her home to check on her and finds the property empty.

12:03 p.m. The family calls 911 to report Nancy missing.

12:14 p.m. Police officers arrive at Nancy’s home.