Blog Details

In July 2006, 34-year-weak Allison Jackson Foy vanished in Wilmington, North Carolina. The mummy of two used to be final considered leaving the Junction Pub and Billiards at closing time.

She used to be never considered alive again.

For virtually two years, her preferred ones searched. Then, in the spring of 2008, human remains were stamp in the woods—correct three miles from the pub.

Authorities thought the remains must glean belonged to Allison, and DNA tests would later voice them correct. What they didn’t protect up for used to be that correct 10 toes away, they would get one other house of remains.

Police think Allison had been killed and her body dumped at that area the night she disappeared in 2006. The second house of remains had simplest been there about half of as long.

It took months, however these remains were at final identified as belonging to 42-year-weak Angela Rothen. She had been missing for approximately nine months when her remains were found.

Investigators believed the cases were linked, however who killed them?

As police labored to resolve that out, Allison’s family hired a non-public investigator named Marc Benson, who bought an electronic mail from a girl named Susan Iannone. She wrote that there used to be pronounce round city that her husband, Tim, had one thing to live with Allison’s disappearance.

Tim Iannone lived across the corner from the pub the set Allison vanished. He used to be working as a cab driver at the time. He had a long criminal epic dating lend a hand to 1979, mostly for larceny and embezzlement.

In 2007 he used to be charged with second-stage kidnapping and assault with a deadly weapon after a intercourse worker accused him of maintaining a field cutter knife to her neck and forcing her to glean oral intercourse. He agreed to plead to a lesser charge of “crime in opposition to nature” and used to be given 36 months of supervised probation. That crime took area now not up to 100 yards from the set Allison and Angela’s bodies were stamp in 2008.

In June 2008, and in connection with its investigation into Allison’s disappearance, the Wilmington Police Division completed a search warrant on Iannone’s house, his autos, his old area, and any cabs he had driven at some stage in the time of the murders.

They found nothing.

Iannone additionally passed a polygraph and supplied his DNA to the authorities.

In November 2008, Wilmington Police acknowledged that Iannone used to be no longer a suspect. A month later, Tim and his companion, Susan, sat down with Dateline’s Josh Mankiewicz for an interview. Tim Iannone denied having any involvement in the murders.

Hearken to the corpulent episode:

All by means of the interview, Iannone said that he understood why the police were investigating him, citing his prior conviction for what he usually known as a consensual stumble upon with a prostitute. But, he insisted, “I’m now not the one who had the relaxation to live with this.”

In 2018, the North Carolina pronounce legislature allocated funds to lend a hand pay for DNA attempting out in backlogged sexual assault cases. In 2021, the Wilmington Police Division submitted a equipment from a 1996 rape wherein the woman had additionally been overwhelmed, held in opposition to her will and abandoned on the facet of the road.

They bought a hit.

The DNA belonged to Tim Iannone. He used to be arrested and charged with rape and kidnapping in November 2021.

“The day that I bought the mobile phone call that he used to be being arrested and charged, you understand, used to be—used to be a plentiful day for my family and I,” Allison Foy’s sister Lisa Valentino truly handy Dateline now not too long ago. The family went to a pretrial listening to at which she says her sister’s name used to be introduced up, as used to be Angela Rothen’s. “It used to be very queer to be in that court docket and search him sitting there.”

Iannone used to be convicted of the rape and kidnapping charges and in 2022, used to be sentenced to wait on as a minimum Forty eight years in detention heart. He’s now not eligible for parole except the year 2074.

“It used to be a small half of resolution,” Lisa said, at the side of that it used to be delicate to stamp, however she felt luxuriate in Allison’s case helped a formulation or the other. “It’s a correct feeling,” she said, “to grab that he is away.”

Lisa has never spoken to Iannone straight, however knows what she would pronounce if she did. “Maybe it’s time that you simply search your admire judgment of right and wrong and your admire heart and, you understand, that you simply—you notify us that you simply—that you simply potentially did this, in sing that the remainder of my family, finally these years, can at final glean a tiny bit of peace—and even perchance in your self.”

Nobody has been charged with the murders of Allison Foy or Angela Rothen. Nonetheless, “I live think that the person to blame for Allison and Angela’s raze[s] is in detention heart,” Lisa truly handy Dateline. “There’s a sense of reduction that he is the set he belongs, and he can’t disaster anybody else.”

She is peaceable decided to glean justice for her sister. “I would luxuriate in my family, and Allison’s daughters in particular, to glean their day in court docket the set they’re in a position to face him and gives an affect victim’s affect reveal and truly let him know what he did, you understand, now not correct in taking the lifetime of my sister, however truly how that affected the lifetime of her young other folks, you understand, now not increasing up with a mother,” Lisa said. “I don’t mediate that I will fully relaxation except she has the justice.”

Till then, Lisa is working to lend a hand other households who glean found themselves in her family’s area. She volunteers for the CUE Heart for Lacking Persons. “I correct truly feel that it’s essential to present lend a hand,” she said. “I do know what it’s luxuriate in and what it feels luxuriate in, and it’s correct so important to lend a hand americans.”

CUE is North Carolina-basically based, nonetheless it helps with missing persons cases nationwide. Lisa volunteers for CUE in Contemporary Jersey, and one among her fresh cases is the April 2024 disappearance of 37-year-weak Danielle Lopez. Dateline interviewed Lisa for Season 4 of the Dateline: Lacking in The United States podcast, which lined Danielle’s memoir in the episode “Misplaced Lane.”

In November 2024, Jason Smith used to be elected district authorized educated for Contemporary Hanover and Pender Counties in North Carolina. Lisa truly handy Dateline she’s been in contact with the brand new D.A. “I’m hoping, um, that he’s taking a new stumble on with new eyes on this case,” she said. “And there’s loads for him to get at. This is potentially one among the greatest case recordsdata in Wilmington, North Carolina’s historical past.”

Smith’s assistant, Samantha Dooies, truly handy Dateline Allison Foy’s case is peaceable “under assessment” by their area of job and confirmed that they’ve been in contact with the family, “however there are no updates besides that,” she said.

Lisa believes there might perchance well well very effectively be other folks available who glean info about what befell to her sister and is peaceable hopeful somebody will attain forward. “I continuously wish to glean hope. Because if we don’t glean hope, we in actuality don’t glean the relaxation,” she said. “Whenever you understand one thing, please, you understand, contact Wilmington PD or the CUE Heart for Lacking Persons and lend a hand—lend a hand my family. And extra importantly, lend a hand Allison glean the justice that she deserves.”

Whenever you’ve got info, please contact the Wilmington Police Division at 910-343-3600 or the CUE Heart for Lacking Persons 24-hour line at 910-232-1687.

Whenever you’ve got a memoir to share with Dateline, please post it right here.