Blog Details

Here’s the set aside to originate for Europe’s lofty objectives of greener air hotfoot – a series level in Malaysia for greasy plastic bottles filled with discarded frying oil, hundreds of miles from its final vacation teach.

One Saturday morning final month in the city of Melaka, volunteers in inexperienced T-shirts rushed over as Adibah Rahim and her husband drove into the central square, desirous to unpack, weigh and register her consignment of ragged cooking oil (UCO) – the “liquid gold” in European plans to ramp up production of sustainable aviation fuel (SAF).

Rahim left the series level 90 ringgit ($21) richer, three ringgit per litre of oil – a gorgeous addition to her family’s household budget.

“We veritably come by UCO from spherical 200 individuals of the final public,” said Michael Andrew, gross sales supervisor for Evergreen Oil & Feed, the company working the Melaka series with the native council and a vendor to leading European SAF producers alongside with Spain’s Repsol, UK-essentially based Shell and Finland’s Neste.

When fabricated from rupture equivalent to UCO, reasonably than agricultural commodities admire soy or palm oil, backers command SAF can cut planet-heating emissions by up to 80% over kerosene jet fuel, without taking on land that would possibly per chance well otherwise be ragged for food crops, or fuelling wooded space destruction.

However in the succor of SAF’s native weather-pleasant facade, a months-lengthy investigation by Local weather Dwelling Recordsdata and its associate The Straits Instances has uncovered an opaque global offer chain that exposes jet fuel companies and their aviation potentialities to significant fraud risks, elevating doubts about the native weather advantages of the sector’s distinguished inexperienced hope for the years forward.

As SAF producers dart for dinky raw materials to meet new blending quotas in Europe and rising quiz in other places, barely ragged and virgin palm oil is being handed off as UCO to traders that offer fuel firms, experts and commerce operators told us. Palm oil that just just isn’t regarded as rupture just just isn’t accredited under European Union solutions for SAF on story of its links to deforestation.

Our reporting centered on the UCO commerce between Malaysia, the sector’s 2d-good palm oil producer, and Spain, the EU’s good aviation market and dwelling to one of its SAF pioneers – oil-and-fuel giant Repsol.

Online fraud Fried in Spain?

Speaking on the World Financial Dialogue board in Davos in January, Repsol CEO Josu Jon Imaz held up his company’s new 250-million-euro ($285 million) plant for renewable fuels, alongside with SAF, approach the historic Spanish port city of Cartagena as an illustration of how Europe can pursue a fair correct, inexperienced transition. Practically half of the plant’s price turned into financed by the EU’s lending arm, the European Investment Financial institution.

Repsol, which targets to reach uncover-zero emissions by 2050, started large-scale production of biodiesel and jet fuel – with its SAF essentially fabricated from UCO – on the plant early final year.

Contrasting this with electric autos, loads of them imported from China, Imaz said the raw topic cloth for Repsol’s renewable fuels “comes from Spanish farms and from the Spanish rural economy”.

In a promotional video for those fuels, Spanish star chef Susi Díaz is considered dispensing advice to young cooks in the kitchen of her La Finca restaurant. Olive oil is then poured out of a pan into metal jugs as a voiceover explains how the rupture cooking residue will be sent to the Repsol biofuels refinery.

Spain’s eating places, alternatively, are not the predominant offer of Repsol’s UCO.

In 2024, more than 126,000 tonnes of UCO from Asia – adequate to get 50 Olympic-sized swimming swimming pools – arrived in the Spanish teach of Murcia, where Repsol’s flagship biofuels plant is found, per commerce recordsdata published by Spain’s tax agency.

Practically two-thirds came from Malaysia, whose UCO exports to the teach saw a 10-fold upward push in the identical year the vitality heavyweight fired up its Cartagena SAF refinery.

The figures discontinuance not specify who supplied or sold the raw topic cloth. However Local weather Dwelling bought a listing of shipments of UCO licensed for the European market that had been sourced from Malaysia by Repsol’s buying and selling unit in Singapore, essentially based on evaluation of customs records supplied by Recordsdata Desk, an investigative consultancy.

Repsol told Local weather Dwelling it “complements with imports when wanted” and receives raw topic cloth shipments from more than 20 countries. It declined to produce more particulars about its imports for “aggressive causes”.

The corporate is promoting the recycling of UCO from Spanish households – of which it says good 5% is presently amassed – at its fuel stations all thru the country. However per the commerce recordsdata, Repsol bought as a minimum fifty three,000 tonnes of UCO from five Malaysian firms, alongside with Evergreen Oil & Feed, in 2024.

No incidents challenging false UCO had been detected in Repsol’s offer chain, with its imports meeting EU solutions on inexperienced certification. However our investigation chanced on the company’s heavy reliance on Malaysian offers exposes it to fraud risks that lift wider questions about global assertions over the sustainability of SAF.

Requested what steps it takes to fight fraud, Repsol said it operates a rigorous vendor monitoring machine to make certain the sustainability and integrity of its SAF production. A “very strong” compliance direction of system doubtful raw materials and suppliers suspected of misconduct are rapid weeded out, it added.

“Repsol firmly rejects any fraud that distorts competitiveness in the sector and helps all initiatives by relevant authorities to fight it,” the company said in emailed comments.

Online fraud Jumpy air hotfoot’s carbon footprint

Europe’s inexperienced aviation fuel refineries are boosting output on story of new requirements by the EU and the UK for planes to make use of more SAF in the approaching decades. From the initiating of this year, fuel supplied to airports all thru Europe needs to possess as a minimum 2% of SAF, with targets rising progressively over the next 15 years, inserting expansive stress on tight global offers.

SAF is required for haunted aviation’s carbon footprint, per commerce body the Worldwide Air Transport Affiliation (IATA), and is anticipated to story for 65% of emissions reductions by 2050, when the sector has committed to reaching uncover zero.

In 2023, emissions from international plane hotfoot accounted for 2.5% of the sector’s vitality-linked carbon emissions. As air hotfoot increases, and other sectors are more without concerns in a space to decarbonise, that share is determined to grow.

Explainer: What’s Sustainable Aviation Gasoline?

Repsol’s Imaz told financial analysts early final year that emissions-reducing selections to SAF – equivalent to restricting rapid-haul flights – would signify “a tumble in the ocean”.

However surging quiz for SAF’s feedstock of replacement, UCO, and a world certification machine essentially based on self-declaration in the starting set aside of the provision chain are encouraging fraud that undermines the new fuel’s inexperienced credentials.

Online fraud ‘Ridiculous’ series numbers

This investigation chanced on that by the time Asia-essentially based traders ship UCO offers out of the country to refineries for processing into SAF, guaranteeing their environmental integrity is on the subject of not doubtless – despite the certification machine on which fuel firms and airlines rely.

A offer at a number one Malaysian UCO vendor to firms alongside with Repsol told The Straits Instances that some UCO collectors and eating places are committing fraud by providing oil that would not qualify as ragged, even supposing it’s refined to level to.

In Malaysia, which is among the many sector’s leading suppliers of each and each UCO and virgin palm oil, authorities-subsidised cooking oil is much less expensive than UCO – providing a transparent incentive for fraud.

In a 2024 fable, Brussels-essentially based environmental group Transport & Ambiance (T&E) cited figures showing that Malaysia already exports about thrice as grand UCO as it’s estimated to come by domestically and import, elevating difficulty about where that oil is coming from – and what it includes.

The evaluation by consultancy Stratas Advisors, ragged as a basis for the fable, says the “tall deficit” signifies the “risks of fraud and palm oil potentially compensating for the shortfall”.

In 2023, 458,000 tonnes of UCO originating in Malaysia had been registered with Worldwide Sustainability and Carbon Certification (ISCC), the leading certification map recognised by the European Payment to level compliance with its biofuels sustainability criteria.

In absolute terms, that places Malaysia 2d good to China. However if all that UCO had been amassed from its population, it would relish had by a ways the perfect volumes per person worldwide: 15.2 litres for every Malaysian inhabitant, when put next with 0.9 litres per capita in neighbouring Indonesia and 3.8 litres in Spain.

Cian Delaney, campaigns coordinator at T&E, said that figure is “ridiculous”, adding that for it to be feasible, Malaysia would must be “a world leading series and refining machine – which it isn’t”.

Online fraud Exactly what it says on the bottle?

The rupture substances from which SAF is made change fingers loads of times in a largely opaque machine. To take a look at their sustainability, European regulators rely on checks by private auditors and companies that difficulty inexperienced certificates essentially based on their findings.

However there is a blind teach: the eating places, motorway stalls, households and factories from which the UCO is pooled self-say the starting set aside and authenticity of their contributions. With the exception of ad-hoc teach checks and sampling, there’s rarely always a technique of knowing that all of these companies are telling the truth.

“The opportunity, or incidents, of fraud is terribly high,” said Vasu R Vasuthewan, the ragged Malaysia head for the ISCC.

Malaysian authorities lately uncovered criminal syndicates that had pocketed hundreds of dollars a day by getting protect of big amounts of subsidised cooking oil, mixing it in with UCO, after which selling it on to industrial UCO traders.

Alternate sources told Local weather Dwelling and The Straits Instances that many households and eating places are motivated to change cooking oil after a single use – opposite to fashioned apply – after which sell it on as UCO. Cooking oil is considered rupture when it’s no longer match for frying – veritably after being ragged between three and five times.

“Restaurant compliance [with sustainability standards] would possibly per chance well be very low,” said Vasuthewan, who now runs his come by UCO import and export commerce. “Many will faux their declaration, hoping they won’t rating caught.”

Malaysia’s Deputy Minister of Plantation and Commodities Chan Foong Hin, who has acknowledged that fraud is a difficulty in the UCO sector, said authorities are “actively monitoring the commerce to discontinuance false activities” and strengthening enforcement mechanisms.

“To protect offer chain integrity, varied measures are in space, alongside with traceability systems, certification requirements, and stringent export documentation,” he told The Straits Instances.

Delaney of T&E said it’s refined for auditors to bodily take a look at the starting set aside of the oil, since hundreds of eating places can offer the identical series level, making it a “distinguished blind teach”.

Online fraud Place checks, patchy audits

In theory, there is a machine in space to protect false stocks out of the provision chain. Investors and regulators in Europe rely on audit firms to price the raw materials ragged in SAF and level to their inexperienced credentials.

Those audits are verified by licensed certification systems admire ISCC – which is led by the biofuels commerce and, per one offer, enjoys “quite quite a bit of monopoly” in the sector. It then elements sustainability certificates to commodities traders and fuel suppliers.

ISCC says its certification direction of helps “sustainable, fully traceable, deforestation-free and native weather-pleasant offer chains”.

But while auditors conduct random enviornment checks in some instances, that happens much less veritably in countries outside the EU, commerce experts command.

In step with James Cogan, compliance and markets lead at Irish biofuel agency Clonbio, it’s plot more uncomplicated for fraud to occur outside the EU where “it’s grand much less considered to us”.

An evaluation by T&E in China, as an instance, showed that sampling of aspects of starting set aside passed off in decrease than 10% of the ISCC-licensed audits, whereas in the EU it turned into about 30%.

Adam Kirby, ISCC’s senior sustainability supervisor, told Local weather Dwelling that auditors show screen volumes coming out and in of series aspects for any suspicious behaviour, to boot to carrying out teach checks.

He added that the ISCC follows the requirements established by regulators admire the European Payment.

In 2024, ISCC also conducted seventy 9 special “integrity assessments” – spherical two-thirds targeting Asia-essentially based suppliers – which independently monitored the work of auditors. In a third of instances, it chanced on violations of its certification requirements, alongside with an inability to level the traceability of merchandise, leading to the withdrawal of 11 certificates.

Online fraud From frying pan to frequent flier

Under the latest machine, your complete SAF offer chain relies on a lengthy paper toddle rooted in those self-declarations and sporadic inspections on the aspects where UCO is amassed.

In Malaysia, Evergreen’s owner CK Lau told The Straits Instances the company follows the “correct processes” in its series essentially based on the requirements established by the ISCC. He added that the documentation is “extreme” as, otherwise, the company wouldn’t be in a space to export its UCO.

Repsol, for its share, said it requires “suppliers to be licensed under European Payment-recognised voluntary regimes”.

In turn, airline firms that purchase from Repsol equivalent to Worldwide Airways Community (IAG) – the parent company of British Airways, Iberia, Vueling, Aer Lingus and LEVEL – rely on documentation they rating from it and other jet fuel companies, to level the SAF they’re paying for has inexperienced certification.

In unprecedented instances, IAG told Local weather Dwelling it has sent its come by group to develop checks on the ground, as with a Shanghai-essentially based Chinese vendor final year. It described the of that audit – which integrated offer, fable-preserving, environmental and effectively being and security requirements – as “particular”.

Robert Boyd, Boeing’s Asia-Pacific sustainability lead who beforehand labored for IATA, thinks airlines’ exacting requirements will teach particular change in the SAF commerce. “You’ll seek for a sprint to the tip… on sustainability, and this would possibly per chance per chance, in a technique, be self-regulated,” he added.

Online fraud SAF certification faces EU scrutiny

Meanwhile, following a string of fraud allegations about the authenticity of UCO-derived biofuels imported from China, the EU has been searching to set up whether the certification machine governments and companies rely on is match for reason.

EU authorities relish been in talks to make stronger that machine, leading to hypothesis that the ISCC will be suspended for failing to procure instances of biodiesel fraud. The ISCC denied in a observation that regulators had regarded as halting automatic EU-large acceptance of its certificates, adding that its relationship with the European Payment remained constructive.

“There’s repeatedly sinister actors, there’s repeatedly sinister people, and there’s good a selected amount of policing that will furthermore be performed in any commerce,” said Kirby. “We at ISCC relish performed, I possess, an incredible job.”

A European Payment spokeswoman said the bloc’s government arm turned into “carefully monitoring” the SAF market “to detect and discontinuance fraud, which risks undermining the EU’s ambition to effectively decarbonise air transport”.

Authorities in the US and Singapore, which needs to space itself as a regional SAF hub, relish also voiced difficulty about fraud in the SAF offer chain.

“We are responsive to concerns raised by varied stakeholders, alongside with the EU and the US, concerning false practices in the SAF offer chain. We share the identical concerns as these pose risks to market self assurance, pretty buying and selling and vogue of a nascent SAF market,” said Daniel Ng, chief sustainability officer on the Civil Aviation Authority of Singapore (CAAS).

He said the authority turned into working with the Worldwide Civil Aviation Organization’s Committee on Aviation Environmental Protection to fabricate “harmonised requirements for feedstock verification to discontinuance additional false practices”.

Online fraud Demand for UCO sizzles

Whatever action regulators rob to protect SAF fraud-free, leading European refiners equivalent to Repsol are pushing for a level global taking part in enviornment to boot to more public funding to teach down costs and succor fabricate the nascent sector on the continent.

IATA warned earlier this month that the European mandates had led to the SAF label paid by airlines to double on story of hefty compliance funds being charged by producers.

Repsol’s aviation head Carlos Suárez Cubillo warned that fuel producers in ingredients of the sector with laxer solutions would possibly per chance per chance fabricate SAF “with much less law and no more take care of watch over of the feedstock… and here in Europe that will de-incentivise the production, the construction of new companies”.

In Brazil, as an instance, an rising SAF commerce is gearing up to make use of reduce-essentially based feedstocks which would possibly per chance well be usually linked to deforestation – and are therefore banned in Europe – equivalent to soy and palm oil, to boot to sugarcane-essentially based ethanol, which has been linked to labour abuses and silent slavery.

An investigation by Local weather Dwelling’s associate in Brazil, InfoAmazonia, chanced on that the palm oil producer in the succor of a deliberate biorefinery in the Amazon teach – billed as Brazil’s first SAF project – is rising the reduce on land areas topic to sanctions by the national atmosphere agency over illegal deforestation, and is struggling financially after rights abuse allegations.

IATA hopes its efforts to set aside in space a world registry for SAF, launched in April as a voluntary initiative, will boost transparency spherical feedstocks and their greenhouse fuel savings – and enable airlines to relish some level of visibility and comparability between countries, fuel companies and airports.

SAF producers and airlines are also taking a seek to other rupture-essentially based materials to meet rising mandates – in particular as more developed fuels fabricated from inexperienced hydrogen and carbon dioxide, usually known as e-SAF, are amassed being developed and examined.

Repsol, as an instance, lately closed a take care of US vegetable oils giant Bunge to offer camelina and safflower – non-food crops that would possibly per chance grow on unfortunate land – to fabricate hydrotreated vegetable oil (HVO) for biodiesel and SAF.

In January, it also announced it would make investments more than 800 million euros ($906 million) in Europe’s first plant in the Catalan city of Tarragona to fabricate “renewable” methanol from natural urban rupture that now ends up in landfill, to be used in maritime, motorway and aviation transport from 2029.

However in the meantime, Europe’s overwhelming reliance on UCO system this would possibly per chance per chance continue to import offers from Asia – despite the troubles over fraud, said Sophie Byron, global head of biofuels pricing at S&P World Commodity Insights.

“That commerce plug just just isn’t going away anytime quickly,” she said.

Online fraud ‘Token effort’ on aviation emissions?

At Repsol’s expansive refinery complex approach Cartagena, the incandescent pipes and metal cylinders of the flagship SAF unit are dwarfed by the positioning’s conventional, fossil fuel-refining infrastructure.

Repsol’s vegetation processed 43.3 million tonnes of rude oil final year, per its annual fable. In inequity, its renewable fuels production capability stands at 1.25 million tonnes per year – of which the Cartagena plant accounts for 250,000 tonnes, alongside with SAF.

It is a token effort against tackling rising aviation emissions, said Pedro Luengo of Spanish environmental community Ecologistas en Acción, standing on a hillside overlooking the complex.

As Spain’s airports prepare for one more fable-breaking summer season vacation inflow this year, Luengo warned that the hype spherical SAF would possibly per chance per chance level to counter-productive in the fight against native weather change by justifying but more air hotfoot.

“As an replacement of progressively substituting fossil fuels with other [green] sources and ingesting much less, what we’re doing is expanding the opportunities because now we relish more fuels accessible to make use of,” he said. “That is more doubtless to be a contradiction.”

This investigation turned into developed with the improve of Journalismfund Europe.

The Straits Instances in Singapore will post a version of this myth in the approaching days.